Saint Clare, directed by Mitzi Peirone, comes with a premise that immediately piqued my interest—blending psychological tension with the religious undertones of its titular character, Clare Beeker. While the film boasts a notable cast, including Bella Thorne in the lead role, along with the familiar faces of Ryan Phillippe and Rebecca De Mornay, it ultimately struggles to find its footing, leaving much of its potential untapped.

Let’s start with Bella Thorne. I’ll admit, she’s not an actor I typically connect with on screen, as her performances often come across as lacking emotional depth. However, in Saint Clare, she does a decent job portraying the enigmatic and haunted Clare Beeker. There’s a fragility to her portrayal that occasionally breaks through, and I found myself more engaged with her performance than I expected to be. That said, there are still moments where her character feels distant and underdeveloped, which keeps the audience from fully investing in Clare’s internal turmoil. It’s as though she’s on the cusp of something more profound but never quite reaches it.

The film also brings back Ryan Phillippe and Rebecca De Mornay, which is a pleasant surprise for anyone who’s missed seeing these two on screen. Phillippe plays his role competently, though there’s not much for him to work with. De Mornay, meanwhile, brings her usual grace and presence, but like Phillippe, her character is underutilized, leaving me wanting more from both actors. Their presence feels more like a nostalgic nod than an essential component of the story.

The true standout, however, is Frank Whaley. Despite being criminally underused, Whaley steals every scene he’s in, offering a refreshing balance between reality and fantasy. His performance adds a much-needed layer of complexity to a film that often teeters on the edge of surrealism but never fully commits. Whaley’s ability to walk the fine line between grounded reality and unsettling fantasy suggests that Saint Clare could have leaned further into its psychological aspects, using his character as a bridge between the two worlds.

Unfortunately, the film’s execution is where things start to falter. While there are moments that hint at something deeper—particularly with its exploration of Clare’s fractured psyche and the eerie atmosphere surrounding her—the pacing is uneven, and the script lacks focus. What could have been an intense exploration of faith, guilt, and redemption gets bogged down by disjointed storytelling and underwhelming tension. The film never fully grips you in the way it intends to, leaving key plot points feeling unresolved or poorly developed.

Visually, Saint Clare has its moments. There are a few arresting images that play with the boundaries between reality and Clare’s inner world, but the cinematography often feels at odds with the tone. Rather than fully embracing the psychological horror or surrealism that the narrative teases, it settles into a more straightforward drama, which doesn’t quite mesh with the potential lurking beneath the surface.

The Prognosis:

Saint Clare feels like a missed opportunity. It boasts a capable cast and an interesting premise, but the uneven execution keeps it from being more than a brief curiosity. While Bella Thorne delivers a better performance than usual, and Frank Whaley shines in his limited screen time, the film fails to maintain momentum or dive deep into its more intriguing themes. It’s worth a watch for the cast alone, but Saint Clare ultimately struggles to rise above mediocrity, leaving me wanting more from what could have been a much darker, more compelling tale.

• Saul Muerte

Catch the screening of Saint Clare at the Sydney Underground Film Festival at Dendy, Newtown.

Screening times and tickets available below:

FRIDAY 13TH SEPTEMBER – 7PM

SATURDAY 14TH SEPTEMBER – 8PM