Paul Duane’s All You Need is Death begins with an enticing premise, steeped in the rich folklore and haunting traditions of Ireland, but as the narrative unfolds, it struggles to maintain the initial tension and promise it sets up. The film, which revolves around a young couple’s discovery of an ancient, taboo folk ballad, dives into themes of love, death, and the dark power of music. While there are moments of disturbing brilliance and an intriguing exploration of Irish mythology, the film ultimately falters in delivering a cohesive or captivating story.

At its core, All You Need is Death is a meditation on the power of music to carry both history and curses through time. The young couple, played with solid commitment by Simone Collins and her co-star Charlie Maher, are collectors of rare folk ballads, drawn into a sinister mystery when they record and translate a forbidden song from the distant past. The weight of the song—carried through generations of women who were forced to bear its cursed legacy—is a compelling idea, and Duane’s vision of an ancient, almost primal force embedded in the music has genuine potential.

The film’s opening scenes are some of its strongest, immersing the audience in the deep, folkloric atmosphere of rural Ireland. There’s a palpable sense of dread and mystery as the couple’s curiosity leads them into darker, more dangerous territory. The exploration of cult-like figures, secret histories, and the uncanny resonance of the song is effective in building tension, and Duane crafts these scenes with an unsettling edge, suggesting that the past is never truly gone—it lingers in the present, carried through cultural artifacts like music.

However, once the initial mystery is established, the film struggles to keep up the momentum. What starts as a fascinating delve into the supernatural and the occult loses its sharpness as the plot meanders, repeating certain ideas without developing them further. While the cursed ballad is an effective metaphor for the way history and trauma are passed down through time, the execution feels drawn out, and the film becomes bogged down in its own mythology. Instead of deepening the intrigue, All You Need is Death falls into a series of repetitive sequences that dampen the initial sense of dread.

Simone Collins is a clear standout in the film, delivering a nuanced performance that captures the slow unraveling of her character’s sanity as the curse takes hold. Her portrayal of a woman caught between the ancient and the modern, the living and the dead, is powerful, and she brings emotional depth to the film even when the script falters. Collins’ ability to convey the psychological toll of the song’s curse elevates the otherwise flat narrative, and her performance alone is worth watching.

The film’s themes of repressed history, particularly in its treatment of women’s voices being both vessels and victims of the curse, resonate on a symbolic level. The idea that the song has been carried through time, forced upon generations of women who had no choice but to bear its weight, is a strong thematic thread, but it’s one that is never fully explored. The horror of being a conduit for something destructive is hinted at but never given the depth it deserves. As the film progresses, these ideas are overshadowed by less compelling plot developments, and the emotional weight of the story is lost in the shuffle.

Duane’s direction is strongest when he leans into the more abstract, mystical aspects of the story. There are visually arresting moments—such as scenes that depict the landscape of Ireland as both beautiful and foreboding, echoing the duality of the song itself—but these moments are too few and far between. The film could have benefitted from a more focused exploration of the ancient, pagan themes it toys with rather than falling into a conventional horror rhythm that feels tired by the time the climax arrives.

The Prognosis:

All You Need is Death suffers from a lack of narrative drive. While it touches on fascinating ideas—such as the inescapability of history, the power of songlines to carry curses, and the dark side of love—the film doesn’t sustain these themes in a way that keeps the audience engaged. What begins as a chilling and thought-provoking journey into the past becomes a meandering tale that loses its bite.

For a film that promises a lot with its eerie concept, it ultimately leaves much to be desired. All You Need is Death is worth a watch for its themes and some strong performances, particularly from Simone Collins, but it never quite reaches its potential, losing steam before the credits roll.

• Saul Muerte

All You Need Is Death is currently streaming on Shudder.